New: Fast Snap Pro is now on Google Play and the App StoreGet the Android app →iPhone app →

Business Growth

Good-Better-Best Pricing for Contractors: How to Offer Options That Close

Good-better-best pricing means presenting three options on every estimate instead of one price — a basic option that solves the problem, a recommended mid-tier, and a premium option with upgrades. It works because it changes the customer's question from "should I hire this contractor?" to "which option do I want?" Many contractors find that most customers pick the middle tier, and some choose the top — raising average ticket size without hard selling.

Why Tiered Pricing Works

  • Choice reduces shopping. When customers get options from you, they're less likely to collect three more quotes.
  • Anchoring. The premium option makes the middle option feel reasonable.
  • Respect for budgets. Customers on a budget still have a "yes" option.
  • Higher average ticket. Upgrades are presented naturally, not as an awkward upsell.

How to Build Your Three Tiers

TierPurposeWhat it includes
GoodSolves the problem at the lowest responsible priceCode-compliant, standard materials, basic warranty
Better (recommended)Best value — what you'd do in your own homeUpgraded materials, longer warranty, extras that prevent future problems
BestPremium experienceTop materials, longest warranty, added convenience or aesthetics

Rules:

  1. Never make the Good option unsafe or substandard — it should be something you're proud to install.
  2. Make the differences clear and concrete (materials, warranty years, features).
  3. Label the middle tier "Recommended."
  4. Keep the gap between tiers reasonable — often 15 to 40 percent.

Examples by Trade

Exterior painting

  • Good: One coat, standard paint, minor scraping, 2-year warranty.
  • Better: Full prep, primer on bare spots, two coats of premium paint, 5-year warranty.
  • Best: Better + trim and doors in contrasting color, caulk all joints, 7-year warranty.

Water heater replacement

  • Good: Standard 40-gallon tank, 6-year warranty.
  • Better: 50-gallon high-recovery tank, expansion tank, 9-year warranty.
  • Best: Tankless unit, recirculation, 12-year warranty.

Lawn care

  • Good: Weekly mowing, trimming, edging.
  • Better: Mowing + fertilization program.
  • Best: Full-service plan with aeration, overseeding and leaf cleanup.

Roofing

  • Good: 3-tab or entry architectural shingles, standard underlayment.
  • Better: Architectural shingles, synthetic underlayment, ice and water shield upgrades, ridge vent.
  • Best: Designer shingles or metal, full ice and water shield, extended manufacturer warranty.

How to Present Options

  • Show all three side by side on one page.
  • Lead with the recommended option and explain why.
  • Mention financing on the premium tier if you offer it.
  • Follow up within 24 to 48 hours — see how to follow up on an estimate.

Common Mistakes

  • Making the Good tier so bare that it feels like a trap.
  • Too many differences, which confuses customers.
  • Offering options on tiny jobs where one price is simpler.
  • Not adjusting tiers based on what customers actually choose.

Track the Results

Watch which tier customers choose over 20 to 30 estimates. If almost everyone picks Good, your middle tier may be overpriced; if many pick Best, raise prices or add a higher tier. See also how to raise your prices as a contractor and how to close more estimates.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is good-better-best pricing?

A pricing strategy that presents three options at different price levels so customers choose the level of quality and features they want.

Which option do customers usually choose?

Often the middle (recommended) option, which is why it should be your best-value package.

Does tiered pricing work for small jobs?

It works best on jobs above a few hundred dollars. For very small repairs, a single flat price is usually simpler.

How many options should a contractor offer?

Three is the standard — enough choice without overwhelming the customer.

Estimate this job faster

Build estimates faster so you have time to offer options. Fast Snap Pro drafts itemized quotes from customer photos using your own price book. Try it free. Start your free trial.

See what an AI-scoped estimate looks like

Send a link, get photos back with a priced estimate — using your own rates, not a generic price book.

Try Fast Snap Pro free